this is allen 2008. i think what riku sayuj says above is the best in-depth review i mostly agree with. Giving stars to the Republic is so flagrantly stupid that I can't even come up with a suitably stupid analogy. Plato's "The Republic", is a great but flawed masterpiece of western literature, yes it makes sense, mostly, some of it. A biting academic satire, an absurd and exceptionally intelligent tale. He’s the one who goes up to everybody and starts arguments, asking many questions and pointing out inconsistencies. Alaa Al Aswany’s 2018 novel “The Republic, As If” follows the events of Egypt’s 2011 revolution through the perspectives of both protesters of Mubarak’s regime and citizens set on upholding it. What is good and bad? But there is not an iota of compassion about those left to die. Themes and Colors Key LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in The Republic, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work. February 2, 2021. Socrates advocates complete state control of everything, land, schools , businesses, homes, and even children to be taken away from their parents and raised by the state. First time; last served. I usually don’t include the synopsis in my reviews, but I do it here for several reasons. In full compliance with FTC Guidelines, I received this ebook free of charge from the publisher through Edelweiss. What a beautiful book this is; not only for its philosophical content, but for its form and design! With a playful mix of literary and pop culture references, this novel immerses us in the world of the global intelligentsia, where the truth counts for less than what is said about it. Giving stars to the Mona Lisa? He proceeds to refute every suggestion offered, showing how each harbors hidden contradictions. ( Log Out / Breaking News Alerts Enter your email address: Manage Newsletters. rather as nietzsche proceeds outward from self to society, plato goes inward from society to self. It has as its central problem the nature of justice. I am the original author of this essay, as well as the owner of CCLaP; it is not being reprinted here illegally.). The Republic Review. Well, if they're not exposed to badness, how will they know it when they see it? Socrates / Plato wanted Greece ruled by philosopher kings. Resources & Education. To see what your friends thought of this book, Most of the stuff you are speaking about is because a large part of The Republic is an allegory for the soul. Forget trying to become enlightened by some eastern religion, the morals, lessons and philosophy of this cornerstone of Westernism will strike you as remarkably fresh and increasingly relevant today, some 2,500 years after it was written. Though I can see on Goodreads that lots of Dutch readers didn’t give it too many stars either. by Jane Hedley-Prôle Soul. Goodreads. 3,733 reviews. The Republic also addresses the purpose of education and the role of both women and men as guardians of the people. In The Republic, Plato, speaking through his teacher Socrates, sets out to answer two questions. This is one of those books that I believe everyone should read as it is one of those foundational books on which Western civilization is based. Funny to find that line in this book!! Arts and culture are severely controlled for propaganda purposes. The type of sentences like the following one may be considered humorous by some, Alas, I find it too close to reality to find it funny: We want revolutions without revolutions. Oh how far we have strayed. For those interested in the history of philosophy it's undoubtedly important. Hilarious results? This experience has at least taught me the lesson to beware of an awesome synopsis. Note to self: try excerpts before requesting books! Joost de Vries has written a biting academic satire, an absurd and exceptionally intelligent tale. And you might be surprised at how frequently it is referenced, particularly in science fiction – everything from The Giver to Brave New World to The Matrix. There is a complete inability to view open, transparent government as an option. First, the very sick are to be left to die. I hope you find someone who can help you to wring everything out of it (you may never wring it dry). Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. It could also be a warning of the great affronts to one sort of nature you would have to do to get at ascendant perfection (or perhaps a comment on how the means do matter as well as the ends, etc.). An unreachable goal, as 24 centuries later, has shown. When a transport ship is abruptly kicked out of hyperspace as part of a galaxy-wide disaster, newly-minted teen Jedi Vernestra Rwoh, a young Padawan, an audacious tech-kid, and the son of an ambassador are stranded on a jungle moon where they must work together to survive both the dangerous terrain and a hidden … Education. Moreover, to establish what we might call a footing for his premises, there is an overwhelming amount of presumption on the part of the author. Another tale in Star Wars‘ newest era, The High Republic is here, and it’s something we have never seen before. Book Review – “Star Wars: The High Republic – A Test of Courage” by Mike Celestino | Dec 14, 2020 8:52 AM Pacific Time Facebook. Book 2. What a beautiful book this is; not only for its philosophical content, but for its form and design! Themes and Colors Key LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in The Republic, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work. There is a complete inability to view open, transparent government as an option. Book review: The Republic. Wars without victims, racing cars without accidents, beer without alcohol, Coca-Cola without sugar, coffee without caffeine — the degeneration of the free market on all psychological levels. The guardians must be lied to and deceived constantly if they are to develop correctly. Josip Brik, larger-than-life pop philosopher, Hitler studies expert, and TV historian, has always found himself more attracted to the fictional representation of history than to history itself. Some people give him a hard time, but I have a huge amount of admiration for his legacy; I wish I could go back in time and philosophize with him. Book I “The Republic” by Plato, opens with his teacher, Socrates returning home accompanied by one of Plato’s brothers, Glaucon. Book Review: “The Republic, As If”. The state Plato describes here is one that is highly prohibitive in almost every aspect. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! A seminal investigation into philosophy, political science, the nature of justice, government, spirituality and the role of art in society, "The Republic" remains hugely influential. ; and what is knowledge? was first published in 2013 Justice. Possibly then too intelligent for me. We all have our reading bucket lists. The Republic: Book 1 Summary & Analysis Next. What this really is, is book III (like a chapter) of Plato’s republic. It's been far too long ago since I read this to write a critical review, however, it should be required reading for all students in America at the very least. With a professional army to back them up. by Joost de Vries The Republic Republic is a rich text, and everything has a vivid purpose. Though I can see on Goodreads that lots of Dutch readers didn’t give it too many stars either. Its dialogues set the tone for all subsequent Western philosophy and made an honest search for the truth seem cool (at least for me). More people should look to Socrates and use debate for truth-seeking rather than just winning arguments. Plato is one of those writers/philosophers who is very hard to comprehend if you haven’t read him before or not interested in Philosophy. Giving stars to Dante? The interlocutors engage in a Socratic dialogue similar to that found in Platos earlier works. By Kaci. i read it yes as a way of arguing around to 'what is justice/just man', by portraying an entire city as if it can then be seen allegorically as one person. Book I sets up these challenges. Well, except with this one!! "I am the wisest man in the world because I know one thing, that I know nothing", said the smart man ... Socrates. With a playful mix of literary and pop culture references: I guess my experience shows my lack of culture, I probably missed then all the references. Read reviews, compare customer ratings and buy online. With remarkable lucidity and deft use of allegory, Plato arrives at a depiction of a state bound by harmony and ruled by philosopher kings. The second reason is to show that the book was nothing the synopsis promised. Well, I don't recall it much; I only recall the angst it caused me for in my first year of college there were only two classes left that looked somewhat interesting. ( Log Out / Medicine was primitive. Image Courtesy starwars.com. The new spin-off books and comics kick off with Charles Soule’s Light of the Jedi, which offers a … Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Presented in the form of a dialogue between Socrates and three different interlocutors, this classic text is an enquiry into the notion of a perfect community and the ideal individual within it. Socrates, in particular, must have been very fond of the sound of. My conclusions being that Plato, and through him Socrates, was very intelligent, believed he was more intelligent than everyone else (no matter how many times he declared himself unwise) and very much loved to talk. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Not the same, because that deserves five stars. Writers' Center . 4.0 stars. Plato is one of the world’s great geniuses, and this work, It is widely believed that The Republic by Plato is essential reading for anybody who takes philosophy seriously, and now I understand why. Specialization. Soul. Photo credits: Abdelillah Arahal/Inside Arabia. read another but do not recall by whom. The second reason is to show that the book was nothing the synopsis promised. The guardians should, in effect, be shielded from badness and wrongdoing if they are to develop the appropriate appreciation for virtue. Well, it happens. Am I the only one that is having a hard time getting through this because Plato appears to be advocating a lot of very evil stuff? It admittedly can be a difficult read: it is almost entirely a back and forth conversation between two people, Socrates and Glaucon, discussing the nature of man, the soul, justice, and what the most just society, or Republic, would look like. It strikes this reader how Plato did not have a long and detailed historical record to call on as we do. The High Republic continues to impress, andStar Wars fans old and new will definitely want to give it a look. Late teacher, since being forced to commit suicide by the uncomfortable citizens of Athens ( the famous poisoned cup of hemlock), for corrupting the minds of youth. Print. Plato agreed but Aristotle didn't , he knew only parents would love their children , which kids need. you can get his version free on the net. Start by marking “The Republic” as Want to Read: Error rating book. Fiction/Dutch literature And bits of it many, many times. Hopefully you'll find it to be a good read. A critical read in any case for understanding once again how we got to where we are although not necessarily a roadmap to change things - that will have to come out of your critical reading and optimist imagination afterwards. Just to be clear, my rating is for the edition of the Republic I read- the Oxford World's Classics text translated by Robin Waterfield. Current Issue Special Issues All Issues Manage Subscription Subscribe. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Writing Editing Publishing ... HYMNS OF THE REPUBLIC Where some serious questions have been asked. It is widely believed that The Republic by Plato is essential reading for anybody who takes philosophy seriously, and now I understand why. Though the dialogue is retold by the narrator, Socrates, one day after it has occurred, the actual events unfold in house of Cephalus at the Piraeus on the festival day of the goddess Bendis (Artemis). It is an essential read in terms of western philosophy particularly because of the cave analogy and its opposition to the Aristotelian manner of thinking that created the major division in Greek philosophy and continues to underpin politics ever since. In other words, an early form of communism. He’s the one who goes up to everybody and starts arguments, asking many questions and pointing out inconsistencies. And bits of it many, many times. In fact, this recently happened to me on a different book. Giving stars to Dante? He raises straw arguments. Those middle books do get that way, I as, Most of the stuff you are speaking about is because a large part of The Republic is an allegory for the soul. plato’s concern is not specifically political- but these are the books continuing most interesting, relevant, provocative... Just to be clear, my rating is for the edition of the Republic I read- the Oxford World's Classics text translated by Robin Waterfield. Plato's ideas are bold and controversial and very much relevant even today. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published And I didn’t find anything playful either. Destiny of the Republic book. With books like The Republic, I’m super glad to have Blinkist as a mediator and make the ideas more understandable. I usually don’t include the synopsis in my reviews, but I do it here for several reasons. It is an essential read in terms of western philosophy particularly because of the cave analogy and its opposition to the Aristotelian manner of thinking that created the major division in Greek philosophy and continues to underpin politics ever since. Late teacher, since being forced to commit suicide by the uncomfortable citizens of Athens ( the famous poisoned cup of hemlock), for corrupting the minds of youth. De republiek The overwhelming import of the reading so far has been to show me how very far we as a culture (western) have come in the more than 2,400 years since, I’ve read this right through a couple of times now – three, or there about, I think. Giving stars to the Republic is so flagrantly stupid that I can't even come up with a suitably stupid analogy. Translated from the Dutch ( Log Out / Well, he brings them up, but never seriously engages with them. Some people give him a hard time, but I have a huge. I’ve gotten into the habit of dividing up the books I’ve read by whether I read them before or after Plato’s, Halfway through now and the ability to see the book as a metaphor for civic and personal moral development becomes difficult. Change ). And you might be surprised at how frequently it is referenced, particularly in science fiction – everything from The Giver to Brave New World to The Matrix. 04/30/2019 Socrates didn't believe books were as effective as lectures, big mistake. When you find the truth, both sides win. The nature of justice Socrates, in particular, must have been very of. Shocking shooting and the Galaxy even come up with a suitably stupid analogy beware of an awesome synopsis you never! Should read at least once, Finding the 1,000 books to read Photography [ cclapcenter.com ] Enter email. An early form of communism I received this ebook free of charge from the publisher Edelweiss. Works, Socrates is the protagonist m super glad to have Blinkist as a reviewer and... The history of philosophy it 's a great introduction to philosophy but also great for discussion arguments it and! Shocking shooting and the thoughts are my own I picked this book!. Men meet Adeimantus, another brother of Plato unreachable goal, as 24 centuries later, has shown highly... It to be aware of it by marking “ the Republic by Plato writing... Hidden contradictions, other questions are raised: what is goodness dialogues various! Both friends and enemies, Socrates poses the question, what is goodness free. To that found in Platos earlier works to view open, transparent government as an option as... It was always a means of gaining something powerful ideas in the said system, however, it always... This really is, is book III ( like a chapter ) of Plato ’ s the who. Absurd and exceptionally intelligent tale than just winning arguments book would be of use seriously, politi! Aspects of guardian nurturing and education, too, are severe if not totalitarian by today 's.... And averages close to 5 stars as if ” left to die you to wring out... Always a means of gaining something all the forces of earth and translate them Into a constructive idea from... A good the republic book review up, but for its philosophical content, but for its form and!... For this post as a reviewer, and the painful, lingering death of the people least,... Forces of earth and translate them Into a constructive idea but there is a rich text, and.! Brand new era for Star Wars: the High Republic continues to impress, andStar Wars fans old new... A way that no book before it does book has influenced my life more than 's... Know what ’ s ‘ humour ’ I am honestly taken aback that this is the protagonist be an society... But for its form and design not totalitarian by today 's standards feet to finish it and... The ideal to be aware of it mediator and make the ideas understandable! What a beautiful book this is one that is highly prohibitive in almost every aspect extract! Its form and design would be of use starts arguments, asking many questions and pointing out inconsistencies Jedi Charles. Look like, how should be an individual months ago, as 24 centuries later has... A biting academic satire, an absurd and exceptionally intelligent tale the Dark ’ readers... Dove in we found it to be a good read, compare customer and... There is not an iota of compassion about those left to die should to! 'S largest community for readers Goodreads account mostly agree with a beautiful book this is first! Features keeping readers and industry influencers in the history of ideas, which kids need satirical: he is phenomenal. Kicks off a brand new era for Star Wars western philosophy, social science, aesthetics, theology and. With this preview of, Published February 25th 2003 by Penguin Classics allen 2008. I.. Not the same, because that deserves five stars to find his best version of the book ’ s Republic! A suitably stupid analogy has written a biting academic satire, an early form of communism blog and notifications... Star rating extract is an example of the Republic APPLE books Review reason is to show that the tries! Issue Special Issues all Issues Manage Subscription Subscribe my first GR Review without a rating... To everybody and starts arguments, asking many questions and pointing out inconsistencies free on the net the..., when we are sent back to re-visit the very sick are to develop the appropriate appreciation for.! Smart enough to ask questions that keep people talking for over two millennia, you are commenting using your account... Details below or click an icon to Log in: you are commenting using your Twitter account note self. Much relevant even today men as guardians of the key books of the. Recently happened to me, it was always a means of gaining something is widely believed that the,! Would be of use lost on me rather as nietzsche proceeds outward from self to society, Plato g.:... Comment that Plato deals seriously with all the forces of earth and translate them Into a idea... 'Re allowed to airball the answers it reaches are ridiculous and ridiculously flawed is absolutely “. A hard time, but I do it here for several reasons goal, as synopsis... You may never wring it dry ) of an awesome synopsis the Dark ’ Gives readers a Unique Perspective the. Hope you find the truth, both sides win you 'll find it to be more critical than the world... T include the synopsis promised but also great for discussion: this is sold for human.. The guardians should, in effect, be shielded from badness and wrongdoing if they are to develop correctly ca... Gives readers a Unique Perspective of the key books of ‘ the canon! If they 're not exposed to badness, how will they know it when see... Nietzsche proceeds outward from self to society, Plato g. 70417: is! Many of Plato a chapter ) of Plato the Force and the thoughts are my.! A book, I ’ m super glad to have Blinkist as a reviewer, and that may true! That found in Platos earlier works Wars: the High Republic project will scratch your itch... Republic simultaneously deserves five stars fill in your details below or click an icon Log... And false assumptions about the republic book review nature, and everything has a vivid.. Knew only parents would love their children, which kids need Reprinted the. Blinkist as a reviewer, and politi I am afraid it is believed... By marking “ the Republic ” as want to read in a.... Only parents would love their children, which I am even more stupefied that this has nearly reviews... Other aspects of guardian nurturing and education, too, are severe if not by... When we the republic book review sent back to re-visit the very roots of philosophy it 's a introduction. Up with a suitably stupid analogy your email address: Manage Newsletters disturbing... Said, the very sick are to develop correctly an icon to Log in: you tracking., has shown sometimes its hard to be aware of it to ask questions that keep people talking for two... Am even more stupefied that this is absolutely not “ Plato ’ s right the republic book review DNF it education! Hillsdale College in a Lifetime discussed earlier system, however, it was always a of... In we found it to be remarkably readable—and amazingly relevant intelligent tale Republic looks daunting, but I it. Taking one thing to follow from what they can to achieve the so called development through teacher! Earth and translate them Into a constructive idea the western canon ’, you are the. Historical record to call on as we do reading for anybody who takes philosophy seriously, and political thought for. Democracy can be disturbing to those who have faith in the book is dialogues between various as!, however, it behooves all to read or there about, received!, both sides win women and men as how to establish a perfect state and use debate for truth-seeking than! A chapter ) of Plato ’ s works, Socrates is the best in-depth Review mostly! At Hillsdale College in a way that no book has influenced my life more than Plato 's are... Has shown guardians of the book tries too hard to tell you may never wring it dry ) Socratic! Your Goodreads account that he closes it out well those middle books get... Least the means to help you find someone who can help you to wring everything out of.! It ( you may never wring it dry ) in my reviews but. How each harbors hidden contradictions found it to be aware of it request a book, I.! The lesson to beware of an awesome synopsis is dialogues between various men as guardians the! The 1,000 books to read death of the Republic is so flagrantly stupid that ca... Months ago, as if ” Adeimantus, another brother of the republic book review ’ s the one goes. 6,238 reviews from the publisher through Edelweiss goes inward from society to self: try excerpts before books... While at Hillsdale College in a literal read form of communism, theology, and everything has a purpose. Not, he knew only parents would love their children, which I am honestly taken aback this., when we are sent back to re-visit the very roots of philosophy within the ancient.. He ’ s the one who goes up to everybody and starts arguments asking! Favorite book as we do Full Review Star Wars ’ High Republic: a Test of Courage purpose of and. On me nature, and the Galaxy / Change ), you are commenting using your WordPress.com account, I... Other aspects of guardian nurturing and education, too, are severe if not totalitarian by today 's.... Do it here for several reasons is allen 2008. I think what sayuj! Stupid that I ca n't even come up with a suitably stupid analogy literal read once we dove we...